Child Care

Top 5 Diaper Rash Creams Based on Experience

Top 5 Diaper Rash Creams

As a mom, one of the things that you should always have readily available in your baby care stash is a diaper cream. You should have this prepared even while you’re still pregnant because the moment you give birth, a barrier cream is already necessary especially since newborns have very sensitive skin. This is the reason why many moms look for the best baby diaper cream even before they have their babies. Although their skin sensitivity declines as babies grow up, diaper rash creams are still a necessity to prevent an outbreak of rashes.

Related: Best Mosquito Repellent for Babies

What to look for in a diaper rash cream

When looking for a nappy cream, there are three things you should look for in a product. The cream should be able to:

  • Protect.

As they, an ounce of prevention… you know the rest. A baby can be significantly uncomfortable if he has rashes in his bum, and an uncomfy baby is a fuzzy one, which makes a tired mom at the end of the day. A nappy cream that prevents rashes is a lifesaver.

  • Relieve.

If it so happens that your baby has rashes (because you haven’t been using diaper creams, or the one you’ve been using are crappy ones), you would need a cream that provides relief to your baby. Rashes are not only itchy, they usually sting too. A diaper cream that soothes is a must.

  • Treat.

Rashes sometimes spread if you don’t treat it immediately. And as we previously mentioned, rashes sting; hurting your baby and making him more fuzzy than usual. A nappy cream that doesn’t treat is a useless one (throw it away!). Zinc is the ingredient that actually treats diaper rash so make sure to check if your product of choice has it.

Your diaper cream must be able to do all these things so you don’t have to buy a different product for every purpose.

In order to come up with a good list, I asked fellow moms personally and online. We can’t just rely on what the brands or companies say because they always think of their products as perfect. The most reliable source is the personal experience of people who actually tried it. I’ve read hundreds of reviews and adding my personal review and experience, I was able to narrow everything down to just five products.


Best Diaper Rash Creams based on Experience

Without further ado, here are the five best diaper creams that you can choose from that has all the qualities mentioned above:

1. Desitin Rapid Relief

Desitin is probably the most recommended diaper cream anywhere! There are several kinds of Desitin, and I recommend getting the creamy version instead of the original one. This cream is good in creating a moisture barrier. Moisture such as pee, watery poop and sweat are what causes rashes. Having a moisture barrier prevents the onset of rashes, which Desitin is really good at.

However, when changing nappies, make sure the skin is perfectly dry first before applying the cream. As I previously said, Desitin acts as a good moisture barrier, which also means it can lock moisture in, which is not good. Also, Desitin diaper cream is not recommended if you use cloth diapers. It’s going to be tougher than tough to remove. If your baby has a nasty rash already, I recommend using Desitin Maximum Strength for diaper rash treatment.

Check Desitin Diaper Relief’s price in Amazon.

Desitin Rapid Relief

Click HERE to view in Amazon

2. Weleda Nappy Cream

If you are looking for a diaper cream that is made from all-organic and all-natural ingredients, Weleda Calendula is the one for you. For something to use on a daily basis for prevention, go for Calendula Baby Cream. For severe diaper rash treatment, use the Calendula Diaper Care/Diaper Rash Cream (some mothers even say this one works where Desitin doesn’t!). This is the most popular nappy cream in UK and the rest of Europe. This works well for eczema, too.

Check Weleda Nappy Cream’s price in Amazon

Weleda Nappy Cream

Click HERE to view in Amazon.

3. Burt’s Bees Baby Bee

Looking for a diaper rash cream that works for cloth diapers? Look no further. It works well for rashes that erupted while using cloth diapers. It contains zinc, which helps in the healing, but is completely safe for cloth diapers. Some moms report seeing stains in the cloth diaper after using Burt’s Bees, but it doesn’t cause repelling so there’s nothing to worry about. There’s a misconception that zinc oxide doesn’t work well with CDs, but that’s not true. It’s the petroleum that causes issues with cloth diapers, so that’s what you want to watch out for.

As compared to other nappy rash creams which are usually free of any fragrance, this one contains shea butter, jojoba seed oil and lavender oil, which smells nice. These ingredients are safe for your baby and even nourishes the skin. You can get just one tube if you want to test it out.

Check Burt’s Bees Baby Bee’s Price in Amazon

Burt's Bees Baby Bee

Click HERE to view in Amazon


4. Aquaphor Baby

Aquaphor is a really popular brand when it comes to skin treatments. This is actually the same Aquaphor as the non-baby type, but packaged differently to make it easier for moms to find. So you can use this for all other skin problems such as chapped lips/skin, minor burns, dry heels, scratches and more. Because it is made of 41% Petroleum, it is not diaper cloth safe.

The only negative aspect of Aquaphor Baby Ointment (for me) is that it is leaning towards the “greasy” side, which I don’t like. I recommend having a tub for baby’s use, and a different tub for your other needs. Although this works as a great barrier to avoid rashes, if you’re looking for severe diaper rash treatment, I would recommend Burt’s Bees Baby Bee or Weleda Nappy Cream. You can get Aquaphor Baby cheaper in Amazon than in Walmart and in drugstores. Plus you can get free shipping if you’re on Amazon Prime.

Check Aquaphor’s Price in Amazon


Click HERE to view in Amazon


5. Mustela 123 Diaper Cream

This is probably the least popular in this list, but this is my most recommended. It has all the qualities I’ve mentioned above — it can (1) protect, (2) provide relief, and (3) treat rashes (hence the name Mustela 1-2-3). You can use it in other areas of the body like inside the knees, elbows and neck where sweat usually accumulates, causing rashes. This diaper cream was used on my baby when he was just a few hours old, and he never experienced any adverse effects. It has a nice consistency, which is easy to put and wipe off. It doesn’t leave any crusty, cake-y residue, as opposed to other creams out there.

Whenever my baby develops rashes in other areas of his body, I just put on a little Mustela Diaper Cream and it heals up in less than 12 hours which is A-M-A-Z-I-N-G! The skin is back to normal! That is why I am absolutely raving about this cream and I wonder why other moms haven’t tried this yet! If you just want to test it out, Mustela nappy cream is available in a small 3.8 oz tube for a price of $9 in Amazon. You can check it out here. Although it’s more expensive than the rest of what I recommended here, it is definitely worth every penny.

Check Mustela’s price in Amazon

Mustela Diaper CreamClick HERE to view in Amazon.


This is by no means a complete list; there are other good diaper creams out there, but these are the ones I (as well as a score of other moms) highly recommend. But we would love to hear what you think. What about you? What’s the best diaper cream that worked for your baby? Share your thoughts and help our community!


  1. This is a great website for mothers who could really use more knowledege of how to go about things, when kids come around life takes on a whole different turn and meaning. Being a mom is a full time job and it is plenty work that is why good planning is the order of the day. Your website is very unique and you have done a great job, i am sure that mothers who come to your website will find it most useful.

  2. Heya Working Momma! Great reviews, thanks. Was interested to see that I hadn’t heard of any of your Top 5
    I’m going to see whether I can get any of these here in South Africa. We’ve used Pure Cream, Epimax Junior and Eucerin Atocontrol Body Care Lotion. I find the Eucerin most effective at clearing nappy rash and eczema quickly.

    1. Hi Lauren! I’m glad you liked the reviews. Most of these brands are available in North America and Europe, I’m honestly not sure if they can be found in other parts of the world. If you’re going to try one of these, my top recommendation is Mustela, I believe it’s available worldwide. I hope you can find it and try it out. Thanks for your comment!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Comments